Best Baking Sheets 2024 Canada. While some people say bare aluminum is the best for even heat conductivity, in our research, we found that both work well and that there are other factors to consider when. I tested dozens of popular cookie sheets to find the best, including internet favorites caraway, great jones, nordic ware, and usa pan.
After hours of baking and tasting cookies—someone had to do it—among other tests, we’ve concluded that the nordic ware naturals baker’s half sheet is the best all. In a large mixing bowl or the bowl of stand mixer, add the butter, brown and white sugar.